Image

Phase: Toddler · Topic: Baby Products · Type: Evergreen · Reading time: ~7 min

The average American child begins toilet training somewhere between two and three years of age — and yet walks into the baby products store to find approximately forty-seven different potty-related items all claiming to be essential. Most of them are not. The core gear list for potty training is genuinely short, and the decisions that actually matter come down to two or three choices. This guide makes them clear.

What often delays potty training is not a shortage of products; it's starting before a child is developmentally ready. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends waiting until a child shows specific physical and behavioral readiness signs — typically between 18 and 30 months — and notes that starting before a child is ready tends to make the process longer, not shorter. If you've arrived here because your toddler is clearly ready, here is exactly what to buy.

The first decision: standalone potty or toilet insert?

This is the choice that matters most, and there is no universally correct answer — but there is a framework for making it.

Standalone potty chairs are freestanding mini toilets that sit on the floor. They are lower to the ground, which means toddlers can get on and off independently without a step stool, and their feet rest flat — an ergonomically important detail that many parents miss. When feet dangle unsupported, some children have difficulty relaxing the pelvic floor muscles needed to pass stool, which can cause withholding. Standalone potties are the better starting point for most toddlers under 2.5 years, especially those who are anxious or cautious about new things.

The BabyBjörn Potty Chair (~$35) is consistently rated as one of the best standalone options — high back, armrests, contoured seat that fits a wide range of toddler body types, and an inner bowl that slides out cleanly for dumping. The Summer Infant Lil' Loo Potty (~$15–20) is essentially the same product at a lower price point and is a genuinely excellent budget alternative. If you want something that converts later, the Summer Infant 3-in-1 Train With Me (~$20–25) starts as a standalone, then the top section removes to become a toilet seat insert, and the base becomes a step stool — useful if you want one product to carry through the full training arc.

Toilet seat inserts are rings that reduce the size of the adult toilet opening. They skip the standalone stage entirely and teach children to use the actual toilet from day one, which means no bowl to empty and no later transition away from the small potty. The downside: they require a step stool, and some children find the height of the adult toilet intimidating early on.

The BabyBjörn Toilet Trainer (~$50) is the most-recommended insert for good reason — it locks onto the toilet rim with two adjustable flanges, has a tall splash guard, and fits both round and elongated toilet seats. The Mayfair NextStep2 (~$45) takes a different approach: it's a permanent toilet seat replacement for your bathroom with a built-in toddler ring that flips down. No remembering to attach or remove a separate piece, and adults can use the toilet normally in seconds. Useful in a family bathroom with consistent use.

Worth knowing: Whatever seat you choose, supported feet matter. If your child's feet are dangling, add a step stool — not just for climbing, but as a footrest while sitting. A child with feet flat and knees slightly above hip level is in the optimal position for comfortable elimination. This is why a two-step stool is often better than a one-step.

Step stools: the accessory nobody talks about enough

A step stool is not optional if you're using a toilet insert or transitioning to the adult toilet. It serves two purposes that parents often only think about one of: helping the child climb onto the toilet, and giving their feet somewhere to rest while they sit.

The IKEA Bolmen Step Stool (~$10) is the budget choice that has outlasted dozens of more expensive competitors — lightweight, non-slip rubber feet, and the right height for most standard toilets. The Munchkin Step Stool (~$15) is slightly sturdier and has a wider platform. For families wanting both climbing and footrest support in one, the Skyroku Toilet Training Seat with Step Stool Ladder (~$35) integrates the seat and step ladder into one foldable unit — the child climbs up, turns around, and sits, with feet resting on the lower step throughout.

The same stool should also work at the bathroom sink for handwashing, which reinforces the hygiene habit immediately. A two-step stool is usually the right call; one step often isn't tall enough to reach both the toilet and the sink comfortably.

The pull-up question, answered plainly

Pull-ups are marketed as a step between diapers and underwear. In practice, most potty training specialists and many pediatric occupational therapists observe that pull-ups can slow daytime training — because they absorb wetness efficiently and feel close enough to a diaper that toddlers don't register the sensation of an accident the same way they would in underwear.

This doesn't mean pull-ups are useless. For nighttime and nap time, they are practical and developmentally appropriate — most children aren't physiologically capable of staying dry overnight until somewhere between 3 and 5 years old, and nighttime dryness happens on its own timeline regardless of training method. Using pull-ups at night while training in underwear during the day is a reasonable and widely used approach.

Cloth training pants (brands like Gerber, Potty Patty, or Charlie Banana's training pants) are the middle ground: they look and feel like underwear, give a child the sensation of wetness after an accident, and have a modest absorbent layer that limits the spread of a small leak. If resistance to the process itself is the bigger issue — not the gear — the guide on handling toddler tantrums and meltdowns covers the underlying reasons toddlers dig in, which applies directly to potty training standoffs. They are not pull-ups and they are not adult underwear — they are a transitional tool that keeps the "wet" feedback intact while reducing the immediate mess.

The most effective transition for most children: start in real underwear during active waking hours at home, switch to pull-ups or cloth training pants for outings and sleep, and move to underwear full-time as accidents become rare. Let your child pick their underwear — whatever character or color they want. The ownership matters.

If you're also working on the method alongside the gear, the step-by-step guide to potty training before age 3 covers the practical sequencing in more detail.

The travel potty: genuinely useful, widely underrated

Once potty training begins in earnest, you will face a situation — a road trip, a long errand, a park without a restroom — where the nearest toilet is either unavailable or so daunting (think auto-flush sensors and industrial acoustics) that your newly training toddler refuses to use it. A portable travel potty solves both problems.

The OXO Tot 2-in-1 Go Potty (~$25) is the most recommended portable option: it unfolds into a standalone potty that fits disposable bags (included, with extras available), and the frame clips together to fit over a regular toilet seat for use in public restrooms. Compact enough to fit in most diaper bags. The Jool Baby Folding Travel Potty Seat (~$20) is a more minimal option if you only need the toilet-insert function for travel.

Disposable potty liners — compatible with both standalone potties and the OXO Go Potty — are worth keeping in the car or diaper bag regardless of which potty you choose. A mid-highway rest stop cleanup is much easier when waste is contained in a bag that seals and ties.

What to skip

Musical and talking potties. The novelty wears off within days, the sounds are annoying, and they add electronic components to a product that just needs to be easy to clean. A plain potty that a child feels comfortable on is better than an entertaining one they sit on for two minutes and then want to get off.

Potty training watches and timers. The concept — regular timed reminders to try the potty — can be implemented for free with any phone alarm or a simple kitchen timer. A $25 watch shaped like a frog is not necessary.

Reward charts with elaborate systems. A sticker chart is fine. A multi-tier reward system with prizes for reaching milestones is more complicated than the task requires. Keep the positive reinforcement specific and immediate: praise for trying, praise for success, no reaction to accidents.

Pull-ups for daytime training. As covered above, they tend to extend the process rather than shorten it. Buy them for night use; use underwear by day.

The complete shopping list

For a toddler who is ready to train, this is the entire list:

A standalone potty or a toilet insert with a step stool — depending on your child's age, comfort level, and bathroom layout. Six to eight pairs of real underwear in whatever style your toddler will be excited to wear. Cloth training pants (four to six pairs) for outings and as a backup during the early weeks. A two-step stool if using the adult toilet. A portable travel potty for outside the home. Waterproof mattress protectors for the bed (two, so one is always available while the other is in the wash).

That's it. The rest is optional at best and counterproductive at worst.

The process will take weeks, not days for most children — and the AAP notes that full daytime control typically comes together between 30 and 36 months, with nighttime dryness often following later. Accidents during this period are not failures; they are information about where your child is in the process. The gear can make things easier. It cannot make things faster than your child's development allows.